Welcome to Pirate’s!
Take a look through our endless supply of delicious ice cream flavors you can’t resist!
Be sure to ask for a sample or two the next time you’re here!
Menu Page 1
Soft Flavors
Homemade Hard Ice Cream
All of our hard ice cream is homemade in house with only the best ingredients! Come try them all!
Cherry Chocolate Chunk
Vanilla based with amarena cherries and dark chocolate chunks
*Gluten Free*
Mint Chocolate Chip
Mint based swirled with stracciatella chocolate
*Gluten Free*
Chocolate
*Gluten Free*
Vanilla
*Gluten Free*
Cotton Candy
*Gluten Free*
Strawberry
Strawberry based with strawberries
*Gluten Free*
Banana Oreo
Banana based with chopped Oreos
Caramel Apple Cake
A lite cookie butter base swirled with caramel apples, cinnamon crunch, and crumbled coffee cake
Fudge Brownie
Fudge brownie based with brownie brittle and chopped up brownie pieces
Peanut Butter Brownie
Fudge Brownie based with peanut butter cups and brownie bits
Salty Dog
Vanilla based swirled with caramel and sea salt dark chocolate fudge
*Gluten Free*
Strawberry Shortcake
Vanilla based swirled with strawberries and homemade crumbled biscuits
Espresso Caramel Crunch
Espresso coffee based swirled with caramel and a coffee crunch
*Gluten Free*
Chocolate Covered Cookie Dough
Cookie dough based with stracciatella chocolate and chocolate covered cookie dough pieces
Cookie Trash
Fudge brownie based with cookie dough, oreos, vanilla cookie crumbles, chocolate covered pretzels, chocolate covered honeycombs and a fudge swirl
Peanut Butter Marshmallow Fudge Crunch
Peanut Butter based with fudge, marshmallow, and crunchy peanut butter
*Gluten Free*
Mint Mudslide
Mint based with fudge swirls, mint oreos, and chocolate covered thin mint pieces
Raspberry Riptide
Black raspberry based ice cream with chocolate chunks and chocolate swirls
*Gluten Free*
Pirates Junk
Amaretto based with caramel, fudge, pecans, cashews, and almonds
*Gluten Free*
Lemon Italian Cookie
Lemon based with a lemon biscuit cookie swirl
S’mores
S’mores based with a s’mores crumble
Black & White Malted Shake
Chocolate and vanilla based mixed with malt powder
Maple Walnut
Maple based with walnuts
*Gluten Free*
Coffee Oreo Fudge
Coffee based with fudge swirls and oreos
VEGAN/DAIRY FREE
Orange Pineapple
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY FREE
Oreo Fudge
Vanilla based with fudge swirls and oreos
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY FREE
Mango Italian Ice
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY FREE
Strawberry Lemonade Italian Ice
*Gluten Free*
Hot Jalapeno Pepper Jam
Flavored with the Mean Jean hot sauce from Fred the Butcher and a swirl of fresh jalapeno jam from Petuske’s farm stand
*Gluten Free*
Unicorn
Vanilla based with purple cloud swirls, confetti sprinkles, and edible glitter
*Gluten Free*
Muddy Waters
Vanilla based ice cream with dark chocolate chunks, chocolate covered pretzels, chocolate covered honeycombs and sea salt caramel truffles
Kings Ransom
Chocolate based with pecan, almonds, cashews, and dark chocolate chips
*Gluten Free*
Peach Cobbler
Peach based with a fresh peach reduction and a cobbler crumble
Chocolate Marshmallow Crunch
Chocolate based swirled with marshmallow and a chocolate crunch
Cherry Chocolate Cheesecake
Cheesecake based with amarena cherries, fudge swirls and cheesecake bites
Heath Bar
Vanilla based swirled with caramel and heath bar
*Gluten Free*
Toasted Praline Pecan Fudge
Praline based with roasted pecans with brown sugar and salt and a dark chocolate swirl
*Gluten Free*
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
Chocolate based with chocolate peanut butter cups and a peanut butter swirl
*Gluten Free*
Blueberry Ripple Chip
Blueberry based with a fresh blueberry reduction swirl and dark chocolate chunks
*Gluten Free*
Pistachio
Pistachio based with pistachio nuts
*Gluten Free*
Cannoli
Imported mascarpone cheese, local ricotta cheese, semi-sweet chocolate chips, and cannoli shells
Butter Beer Crunch
Calling all Harry Potter Fans!
Harry Potter’s butter beer with a butterfinger crunch
Chocolate Chip Toasted Coconut
Toasted coconut based with toasted coconut and dark chocolate chunks
*Gluten Free*
Strawberry Lemon Crepe
Lemon based with buttercream frosting and a fresh strawberry reduction
*Gluten Free*
Cookie Butter
Cookie butter based with a cookie crunch and dark butter swirls
Salted Sailor
Salted caramel based with a caramel fudge swirl and dark chocolate chunks
*Gluten Free*
Strawberry German Chocolate Cake
German chocolate cake based with strawberries
*Gluten Free*
Coffee
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY FREE
Cookie Butter Fudge
Cookie butter based with a fudge swirl
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY-FREE
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Fresh strawberry based with strawberries and stracciatella chocolate
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY FREE
Raspberry Cheesecake
Cheesecake based with a fresh raspberry reduction
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY FREE
Chocolate Chip
Vanilla based with dark chocolate chips
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY-FREE
Chocoloco
Chocolate based with a fudge swirl
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY FREE
Coffee Chip
Coffee based with dark chocolate chunks
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY-FREE
Fudge Chips
Chocolate based ice cream with a stracciatella dark chocolate swirl
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY-FREE
Triple Berry Cheesecake
Cheesecake based with a berry swirl
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY FREE
Banana Fudge
Banana based ice cream with a vegan fudge swirl
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY FREE
Blue Monster Italian Ice
Blueberry flavored Italian ice
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY FREE
Blue Raspberry Italian Ice
*Gluten Free*
VEGAN/DAIRY FREE
Margarita Italian Ice
*Gluten Free*